The Art of R Programming: A Tour of Statistical Software Design Reviews

Comments

3 responses to “The Art of R Programming: A Tour of Statistical Software Design Reviews”

1. 

   Sitting in Seattle

   January 30, 2014

   122 of 124 people found the following review helpful

   
   Excellent guide to the R language, November 4, 2011

   By 

   Sitting in Seattle (Seattle, WA) –
   
     

   Amazon Verified Purchase(What’s this?)

   This review is from: The Art of R Programming: A Tour of Statistical Software Design (Paperback)

   There are hundreds of R books, but this is the best one to address the core problem of learning to *program* in R. As reviewer Jason notes, R is used by several audiences with varying needs, but anyone who uses R for long must come to terms with learning to program it. This is the book for that.

   What Matloff does is to lay out the essentials of the R language (or S, if you prefer) in depth but in a readable fashion, with well-chosen examples that reinforce learning about the language itself (as opposed to focusing on statistics or data analysis).

   I’m a long-time (12 years) R user, which is my platform for analytics every day, and I have programmed in a variety of languages from C to Perl. I have long missed the fact that there is nothing for R comparable to Kernighan & Ritchie (“K&R”, The C Programming Language) or similar programming classics; finally there is. Matloff is not quite as beautiful and elegant as K&R (and to be fair, is not in their position as the language creator) but this book has similar goals and comes reasonably close.

   I think there are two primary audiences for this book: those who are learning R from a computer science or programming background; and statisticians and others who use the programming language and want a thorough exposition. In my case, for instance, despite having written perhaps 100k lines of R code over the years, there remained areas where I was uneasy (e.g., exactly how do lists relate to data frames). Matloff sets it all straight, in friendly, readable fashion. Even in rudimentary chapters, I learned shortcuts and miscellaneous functions that are quite useful. The examples throughout are more “CS-like” than statistical, which is highly advantageous for this topic.

   In addition to the tutorial content, it is well-suited as a quick reference. It doesn’t aim to be comprehensive from a function point of view (which is almost impossible, and what R Help is for), but it is comprehensive from a programming conceptual point of view.

   In short, if you program R, and unless you’re a member of R-Core, then I believe you’ll enjoy this, will learn something, and will refer back to it repeatedly.

   0

   Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

   Was this review helpful to you? 
   

   
   |

    Comment

2. 

   Dimitri Shvorob

   January 30, 2014

   46 of 48 people found the following review helpful

   
   Valuable addition to R bookshelf, October 30, 2011

   By 

   Dimitri Shvorob –
   
     

   This review is from: The Art of R Programming: A Tour of Statistical Software Design (Paperback)

   Jason’s juxtaposition of “data analysts” and “serious R programmers” strikes me as a little unfair, but I see what he means. Consider yourself a “serious R programmer” (SRP), and buy this book, if you are interested in the following aspects of R:

   Variable scope – Chapter 7
   User-defined classes – Ch 9
   Debugging – Ch 13
   Profiling and performance (mostly, vectorization) – Ch 14
   Interfacing with C/C++ and Python – Ch 15
   Parallel computation (“pure R” approach using “snow” package, and C++-aided approach using “OpenMP” library) – Ch 16

   I have not seen the material of Chapters 15-16 in any other R reference; the other topics have shown up elsewhere – in “R in Nutshell”, for example – but get more attention here. The chapters would have been much shorter if written in a “Nutshell” style; however, I do not automatically consider a verbose, user-friendly writing style a negative.

   The early chapters introduce R in a way similar to other books – except for (a) eschewing discussion of the language’s statistical repertoire, which makes sense given “programming” focus, and (b) showing a greater interest in the “matrix” class – and although they do it quite nicely (this said, let me ask the author to reconsider his “extended examples”), I would not recommend “Art of R Programming” to non-SRPs, and point them to Robert Kabacoff’s “R in Action” or (the E-Z version) Paul Teetor’s “R Cookbook” instead.

   Overall, while the book did not quite click for me – I am a “data analyst” and at present do not have much “need for speed” (cf. C/C++); on the other hand, I would like a firmer grasp on R’s OOP, but here, “Art of R Programming” only whets one’s appetite – I cannot deny its quality and unique value for budding SRPs. If there was any wavering between four and five stars on my part, the appreciation of how pretty and inexpensive the book is tipped the scales.

   0

   Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

   Was this review helpful to you? 
   

   
   |

    Comment

3. 

   Quikwitt “sdb_8”

   January 30, 2014

   34 of 38 people found the following review helpful

   
   OK but somewhat disorganized, July 6, 2012

   By 

   Quikwitt “sdb_8” (portland, or United States) –

   Amazon Verified Purchase(What’s this?)

   This review is from: The Art of R Programming: A Tour of Statistical Software Design (Paperback)

   This books main strength is also its greatest weakness, it tries to be too much of everything to everyone. The author obviously is a great R programmer (as he will demonstrate way too much) having a masters degree in CS and teaching R at college. However often he is too clever by half, adding non-relevant examples of overly complex and somewhat confuted code. I think he is doing this more out of love for the language then to show off but the effect is the same, much of the book comes off as disorganized and too complex for the beginner/intermediate R user to be helpful given the topic discussed. I will say that anybody who buys this book will find something to about it to like, so it is a useful addition to any R library.

   Iterating the main theme, the book is very desultory. Especially when comparing it to a great book like “R Tutorial and Exercise Solution ” by Chi Yau, which is organized properly. In the first few chapters of The Art of R Programming the author will lay out and explain some basic concepts and code examples then in the next page he is showing how to manipulate various data frames with 12-20 lines of complex code. I’m not sure what audience is reading introductory chapters and would find this abstruse and erudite code useful at all given the basic chapter concepts. Also the chapter layout itself seems odd as salient and trivial topics get uneven treatment relative to their important in the real world. As a Engineer and a holder of a CS degree myself, it isn’t as if the code is too complex per se, its just too complex and superfluous given the topic discussed.

   The author would have been much better served saving the fancy coding to advanced topics in which it would have been more relevant later in the book.

   0

   Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

   Was this review helpful to you? 
   

   
   |

    Comment